User blog comment:Bloody18/The Last Hope Speculation/@comment-3988604-20110730042413/@comment-3438305-20110822195324

no, none of these cats were reincarnated! When you are Reincarnated, you don't remember anything from your past life (So not cinderpelt/heart), and the whole legend of it is you need to learn everything before leaving to "the other world", so hte reincarnated cats would have a different lifestyle, personality, and probably even pelt color. I'm a Buddhist:)