User blog comment:Bloody18/The Last Hope Speculation/@comment-3988604-20110730042413/@comment-4858726-20110806165722

I think Starclan reincarnated Cinderpelt because Cinderpelt's real dream was to become a warrior, not a med cat. Cinderheart is a reincarnation of Cinderpelt, and she's living her dream as a warrior. Firestar already lived his dream, and so far the only cat that has been reincarnated was Cinderpelt, and that was because Cinderpelt was never able to fulfill her dream. I don't see any reason why Firestar would be reincarnated. But that WOULD be cool!